Hi Tyler,
As an owner of Tudor Pelagos, I would like to share my personal experience to all. I purchased this watch in Oct 2012 and since, I had been wearing it during most of the week days till now. I guess I need not detail out on the specs of this watch as i believe most watch collectors are well aware. Please find my personal rating as summarize below,
Scale fm 0 (worst) to 10 (excellent)
1. Comfort: 9
This watch nicely fits my 6.75 inch wrist.
2. Built: 10
As solid as any rollie that i have owned.
3. Movement: 8
I am pretty satified with the performance of ETA 2824 which according to the Tudor specialist, it is of top grade. Accuracy wise is within COSC range. Mine has been consistently running at +3 s per day since day one. The slightest thing that bothers me if i have to comment is the standard 38 hrs power reserve.
4. Bracelet: 10
One of the best bracelet i have ever worn in terms of comfort ( light due to titanium) and easiness for adjustment purposes.
5. Lume: 10
So far this is one of the best lume i have encountered apart from Ball watches. Simply impressive. Only when you have owned it, you can tell.
Conclusion: I must say that Pelagos is truly an awesome model which is definitely value for money considering it as a proper diver watch with water resistant of 500m (HEV). The quality of the built is definitely on par with any rollies except for its movement. The only downside is the resale value for Tudor watches which I believe most watch collectors are well aware of. If I have to recommend any friend for any diving watch, this one will surely be the top list.