I followed that thread rather closely. Even posted a reply or 2, to poke holes. Yeah, I was naughty.
But my memories about the thread was that it contains a myriad of information and solid opinions from a good number of owners/knowledgeable people/sifus.
I went back to read that thread again. I think MWF should be proud. And especially Ristians too. What came out from a controversial statement (and some heated arguments) was a thread where one can learn so much about Panerai (and other watches). In fact, if anyone were to ask me where to learn more about Panerai, I wont hesitate to guide them to that thread.
When that thread was still alive, i was in fact hunting my first Panerai. Today? I am closer than ever in getting one. I am not saying that the Panerai side won the debate there. Just highlighting an example where a noobie like me can learn, freely about watches and from there on, make a telling move for my next step in watch ownership
Pick up any glossy, super duper expensive watch magazine today and all you get are photoshopped pictures and the usual `this is the best, this is a must buy' columns. Visit the usual popular watch forums and in particular the subsection for a particular brand, and you'll see the usual wrist shots, the usual `oh so nice, oh so beautiful, oh i miss this, oh this is the best' comments. I am super proud that in comparison, a MWF thread can contain so much horological nuggets.
And now, if we have really reached a stage ( I agree with some of you, we need to verify if this is true) that there are people demanding an apology, and even to the extent of individuals declaring they won't want to post here anymore, its really sad.
People wear watches. Its expected therefore to read frustrations, disappointments and sometimes even anger associated with a brand. LEts therefore move on to enjoy learning about watches and more importantly, lets move on to enjoy knowing the people owning these watches. I can't share enough how watches, MWF, etc, have brought me valuable friendships.
As the Joker once said..`Why SO serious?'