Well, those are the rules of the forum. We just have to abide to it. The whole reasoning behind the 'no name' policy i believe is that the forum does not want to bear any responsibility for promoting a particular shop and when things happened, the forum is liable for it. What would be a better solution is where the query is put out, that there is a prompt pm response from the mods who know and read the query? Just bear in mind that asking for the name of the shops and asking for discounts given by the shop is 2 different matters altogether. What the dealer will give to one is not the same as the other. It would depend on how many pieces one has bought to warrant that special treatment, how long they have been friends etc etc...so for questions on discounts, i dont think it is really appropriate.
Yes, in all forums, the rules are set by the forum owner/moderators.
We, as members, should abide by them. If we do not agree or dislike the rules, IMO we shold go elsewhere and not start a "war" in the forum.
In MWF case, I concur with G.Mac's comments.
"The whole reasoning behind the 'no name' policy i believe is that the forum does not want to bear any responsibility for promoting a particular shop and when things happened, the forum is liable for it."
It will reflect badly on MWF if things do not go on as expected or not as expected by the members when dealing with the shop(s) mentioned in the forum. Hence no name (or even abbreviation) of the shop(s).
For members who wants to know the shop name, use other means like pm.