PP Nautilus 5711 blue dial vs AP Royal Oak 15202st 40th Anniversary!

[dpkong]

I am not moved by either one of these watches. Does this make me weird?

Not at all. If we all had the same desires, we'd be married to the same woman!

That aside, I'd get the 15202 first, then the 5711 but in white.

[Godzillaz]

Interesting.

I had a similar thought. I would get this AP and a grey dial nautilus chrono (5980)

I am not moved by either one of these watches. Does this make me weird?

Not at all. If we all had the same desires, we'd be married to the same woman!

That aside, I'd get the 15202 first, then the 5711 but in white.

[rkch1975]

The AP really does it for me. The build and bracelet is simply gorgeous for daily use. The only pain that I experienced is when I got some hairline scratches on them  .
 

[Smaug]

Assume that the price of Pp is cheaper by 25k+ then Ap. Now Pp or Ap?

[Godzillaz]

I'll still go with AP. Visually it's a more interesting watch.

The Nautilus has it charm but in the long run the 15202ST is much more satisfying.

Regard
Tyler

Assume that the price of Pp is cheaper by 25k+ then Ap. Now Pp or Ap?

[timenut]

I much prefer the look of the Nautilus.

[theseira]

I much prefer the look of the Nautilus.

Me too!!! I just saw second hand one for sale but the price is bad =(

[G.MAC]

I do not think the price of the nautilus will be any lower after this. I remembered the time when I missed out on one 3 years back where it was going for RM45,000 used and when I pondered a while over it, it was sold and the next one i saw 6 months down the line was RM52,000 used.

[theseira]

I do not think the price of the nautilus will be any lower after this. I remembered the time when I missed out on one 3 years back where it was going for RM45,000 used and when I pondered a while over it, it was sold and the next one i saw 6 months down the line was RM52,000 used.

Ok well the one I saw is RM 79,600. so yeahhhhhhhhhh! 

[el118]

I do not think the price of the nautilus will be any lower after this. I remembered the time when I missed out on one 3 years back where it was going for RM45,000 used and when I pondered a while over it, it was sold and the next one i saw 6 months down the line was RM52,000 used.

Ok well the one I saw is RM 79,600. so yeahhhhhhhhhh! 

I think I saw it too. For a used SS basic watch at that price, I want to siok sendiri but just couldn't pull the trigger. 

[farhanbh100]

this is difficult.. ived always admired ap ro but theres no denying pp noti higher pedigree..
apro4me

[APLOVER]

Nautilus is THE men's watch to have. AP's can have many many anniversary editions. But Nautilus is a must have.

[theseira]

Guys my dealer said he will be getting the piece I want some time this year. Only one piece he will get at a very good price. I have put down a RM15k Deposit for it and now am waiting. Hopefully I can get it in few months time! 

[el118]

Guys my dealer said he will be getting the piece I want some time this year. Only one piece he will get at a very good price. I have put down a RM15k Deposit for it and now am waiting. Hopefully I can get it in few months time! 

The 5711 blue dial? u are getting from AD or grey?

[theseira]

Guys my dealer said he will be getting the piece I want some time this year. Only one piece he will get at a very good price. I have put down a RM15k Deposit for it and now am waiting. Hopefully I can get it in few months time! 

The 5711 blue dial? u are getting from AD or grey?

Maybe 5711??! maybe RO???

I'll be getting mine from grey of course. AD's I can only go in to test test and get free drink  haha can't buy from them. 

Anyways was in SG last month they had RO, price up though. Also visited Cortina PP AD's at marina and Hourglass at orchard seems like 5711 no stock.

[el118]

Guys my dealer said he will be getting the piece I want some time this year. Only one piece he will get at a very good price. I have put down a RM15k Deposit for it and now am waiting. Hopefully I can get it in few months time! 

The 5711 blue dial? u are getting from AD or grey?

Maybe 5711??! maybe RO???

I'll be getting mine from grey of course. AD's I can only go in to test test and get free drink  haha can't buy from them. 

Anyways was in SG last month they had RO, price up though. Also visited Cortina PP AD's at marina and Hourglass at orchard seems like 5711 no stock.

5711 blue is on waiting list, i think no AD is carrying stock. PP KLCC has a white dial.

[mswong]

I have the older white dial AP 15202 and also the blue PP 5711. Both wear differently. Whichever one you are getting first, you will lust for the other one later. Thanks.

[theseira]

Guys my dealer said he will be getting the piece I want some time this year. Only one piece he will get at a very good price. I have put down a RM15k Deposit for it and now am waiting. Hopefully I can get it in few months time! 

The 5711 blue dial? u are getting from AD or grey?

Maybe 5711??! maybe RO???

I'll be getting mine from grey of course. AD's I can only go in to test test and get free drink  haha can't buy from them. 

Anyways was in SG last month they had RO, price up though. Also visited Cortina PP AD's at marina and Hourglass at orchard seems like 5711 no stock.

5711 blue is on waiting list, i think no AD is carrying stock. PP KLCC has a white dial.

EL apparently white dial easier to get u probably know this. Blue problem if want to get it below rrp.

I have the older white dial AP 15202 and also the blue PP 5711. Both wear differently. Whichever one you are getting first, you will lust for the other one later. Thanks.

I am afraid that your right Mswong haha 

[mswong]

Two old pictures to share

AP 15202

PP 5711

[theseira]

Two old pictures to share

AP 15202

PP 5711

Those look good! can't wait till I get mine now haha. very nice pics!

[el118]

I have the older white dial AP 15202 and also the blue PP 5711. Both wear differently. Whichever one you are getting first, you will lust for the other one later. Thanks.

Thank god there is nothing to stop u to get BOTH. Not the same situation if u r stuck with two gf

[toypoodle]

Is pretty hard to choose, altho from same designer but both are totally diff league

In this case for me, it depend on my age, if I were 50 above with children at abt 20 year old, go for pp

If I'm single or no children or still young, I'd go for ap

Well, just me 

Sorry to barge in,  I beg to differ.

If you were 50 & above, you won't go for the Nautilus. Instead, you would aim for Calatrava, which give you a sense of sophistication, regardless its a basic model or grand complication.

[cscdt]

PP of cos for its long  history ! Stand out after all good and bad!