Am_Sober
Just read your post even though its about a year old.
Before I start, let me clarify that All Weather Compact Camera photo quality does not compare DSLR or equivalent.
Nor do I work for Nikon

. I am just sharing my Nikon AW100 experience.
I have been using the Nikon AW100 since 2011 for outdoor and under water pic and its still as good as ever

.
The photo quality is quite decent but the video is even more impresive especially on HD.

I have dropped it (intentionally and accidentally) to proof its hardiness since it was under warranty back

then Underwater photography (video shooting even under water), Sat / stepped on it..
And the old thing still works.
Our company had to replace on an average 6 digital camera yearly (breakdown due to drop, water damage etc)
before we changed over to Nikon AW100 for our outdoor / field report photo and video.
We have not replaced any of the Nikon AW 100 or AW110 over the last 2 years or since acquiring them.

We have about 20 units of AW 110 and AW 100 in my company now and we will acquire another
10 - 20 units of these this year pending on our project needs.
This is my 2 sen worth.

Jimmy Wong