I think it's important to know which type of watch you are looking for...i.e. Divers, Pilot, Dress...etc
But if unsure, then maybe need to find out your taste - plain looking? or complicated? or even 'funky'? Chunky?
Looking at your initial post you prefer one that comes with a steel bracelet...
Personally, I like the Oris BC4 (Pilot) series...which after discount can fall around your budget range...
Ball is a good choice as well well-known for it's night lume and anti-magnetic properties...
Maurice Lacroix you may get only a basic model if getting from an AD at that range...but they make nice dress watches.